Decorated canvas bag with Crayola Fabric Markers (I bought ours at Hobby Lobby for $5.) I LOVE that S is now drawing our family! Daddy is holding a heart :)
Lacing cards made from craft foam and shoelaces (Noah's Ark and a cross)
Simple puzzle printed on cardstock and cut (or you could use religious greeting cards)
Coloring books, a small children's bible, religious stickers (Dollar Tree and Christian bookstores)
I plan to swap some things out and add some vinyl cling, felt, or magnetic biblical scenes...can't decide.